Delhi college academics struggle attendance app over privateness fears – Occasions of India

    As Covid-19 shuttered India’s colleges and overwhelmed its hospitals, academics in Delhi have been roped in for emergency duties – from handing out meals rations to staffing vaccination centres, usually at nice danger to themselves.

    However many baulked when instructed to obtain an attendance app on their cellphones that would observe their location – including to hefty surveillance measures within the capital’s colleges that critics say infringe the privateness of scholars and employees.


    You have got efficiently solid your vote

    Warned by metropolis authorities that their wages could be withheld in the event that they did not comply, the academics are combating again.
    “We weren’t consulted on this app, we weren’t instructed about its options – we have been simply despatched a hyperlink and ordered to obtain it on our cellphones,” stated Vibha Singh, a senior vp of the Nagar Nigam Shikshak Sangh (NNSS) academics’ union.

    After quite a few complaints, the union filed go well with on the metropolis’s Excessive Courtroom final month, arguing that the app violated their privateness. The subsequent listening to is due on Sept. 27.

    “These are our private telephones, and the app tracks our location always. We do not know what different info it will probably entry, or who has entry to the info – what if it will get hacked? Girls academics are particularly in danger,” Singh stated.

    Even earlier than the app was launched, a few of Delhi’s public colleges had closed circuit tv (CCTV) cameras with facial recognition expertise, a measure digital rights advocates have condemned as an “overreach”.

    India’s capital is among the many world’s most surveilled cities, with greater than 1,800 cameras per sq. mile – the best focus globally, in keeping with estimates by expertise web site Comparitech.

    An official on the South Delhi Municipal Company (SDMC), which is the defendant within the academics’ union’s lawsuit, stated the app merely logs the attendance of academics and poses no privateness or security dangers.

    “It’s a misunderstanding that the app can compromise their privateness. We now have held a number of talks with the academics to elucidate the app and to allay their fears,” stated Muktamay Mandal, deputy director of training at SDMC.

    “We’re transferring in direction of elevated digitalisation in each sphere – we’re downloading so many apps on a regular basis. In the event that they don’t have anything to cover, what’s there to concern?” he instructed the Thomson Reuters Basis.


    The coronavirus pandemic has prompted governments and companies to launch a wide selection of applied sciences on the grounds of well being and security that may observe individuals, with few privateness safeguards, digital rights specialists say.

    More and more, employees are pushing again towards what they see as a violation of their rights.

    Municipal workers within the northern Indian metropolis of Chandigarh protested final 12 months towards GPS-enabled monitoring smartwatches they have been required to put on, with the info that was gathered linked to efficiency rankings and salaries.

    Earlier this 12 months, hundreds of government-accredited group healthcare employees – who’re principally girls – protested towards a cellular app they stated tracked their location and recorded their efficiency.

    With the attendance app, the extent of surveillance from monitoring and accessing information can’t be justified as a way to log attendance, stated Anushka Jain, an affiliate counsel at digital rights group Web Freedom Basis in Delhi.

    “There isn’t any want to trace them all through the day; that’s surveillance. It’s totally problematic that these apps and applied sciences are being pressured upon individuals with none information safety pointers,” she stated.

    “The rising pushback we’re seeing is just not solely about the proper to privateness, but in addition as a result of misuse of those applied sciences is so rampant and other people perceive that the worst-case situation is not only hypothetical, it’s extremely probably,” she stated.

    An extended-delayed Private Knowledge Safety Invoice that goals to create a framework for what sort of information will be collected, and for the way it’s collected, processed and saved, will impose penalties for the misuse of any private information.

    However the draft invoice incorporates quite a few exceptions, notably for presidency companies, Jain stated.

    In Delhi, college academics beforehand used a biometrics machine or logged on to an internet site to log their attendance, stated Singh, a faculty principal, however these choices have been changed by the app.

    A number of academics who did not downloaded the app have had their wages withheld, stated Singh, including that the requirement was additionally problematic in households with just one smartphone that could be utilized by different family members in the course of the day.

    “If we should use this app, then give us separate gadgets that we are able to use for attendance and different college work,” she stated.

    “We are able to then go away the machine within the college, and know it’s not monitoring us. We now have no objection to that.”

    Recent Articles


    Related Stories

    Leave A Reply

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Stay on op - Ge the daily news in your inbox